Hannah Huxley, England 1832
Anais Mitchell’s head on tackle of the immigration dilemma is one of the most expertly crafted works I have run across. It’s yet another shining example of how a three minute plus piece can lay bare a complex issue. The song structure builds from the poignant rhetorical questions posed by narrator Greg Brown as a yearning female chorus attempts to weave back answers to them. The dialogue’s atmosphere is brooding and shadowed by uncertainty.
Perhaps her careful repositioning of the relationships between the enemy, poverty, work, freedom, children and wall building allow us to see each in a new way. Which of them is the largest elephant in the room? But in her diorama we can experience a place to examine both how they influence one another and how their interplay might be different. Music often provides such testing grounds . A setting to simplify, maybe the skills to learn when to duck, or draw back the curtain of obfuscation. So if this is an issue of interest to you, give this formidable contribution to solving it a few listens.